I am still awarding it a perfect 10, however, just to counter the butthurt communists. That is apt to change soon, however, it's still somewhat of a bummer that these mods can't be used immediately. About the only thing that keeps me from giving this game a perfect 10 is the fact that it currently lacks mod support - so all of the great Doom 3 mods cannot be enjoyed with this version - yet.

The extra content and improved lighting make Doom 3 BFG a great deal. I guess whether or not one can give this game a good review depends entirely on whether or not they liked Doom 3 - which the Doom community is split down the middle on. However, for someone who doesn't own Doom 3 and/or the early Doom games, Doom 3 BFG is an excellent choice. With that said, I would be reluctant to recommend this version to someone who already owns all the Doom games. While I understand that a lot of people are angry that this game is essentially the same game that was released in 2004 (and without major While I understand that a lot of people are angry that this game is essentially the same game that was released in 2004 (and without major changes), I highly question whether or not most of these user reviews are from true customers or just a bunch of butthurt communists angry that ID Software is making money on Doom 3 again.

Doom 3 vs bfg edition